Midseason grades — how the first round is holding up
The PAFL draft is now far enough in that the early returns are telling. Each pick below carries its original draft-day grade and its updated midseason grade, based on rookie production through the first half of the 2026 season. The first-round board has already split into clear winners and clear busts. Linebackers have carried the class, quarterbacks have barely played, and injuries have trimmed several highly rated players.
| RISERS | FALLERS | HOLDING |
|---|---|---|
| Trotter (LB) · Thieneman (S) · Rodriguez (LB) · Styles (LB) · Boston (WR) · Reese (LB) · Delane (CB) · Mesidor (EDGE) · Concepcion (WR) · Ioane (G) · Hill (LB)* · Johnson (CB) · Tate (WR) | Bain (EDGE) · Mendoza (QB) · Downs (S) · Love (RB) · Lemon (WR) · Lomu (OT) · Bailey (EDGE) · Fano (OT) · Proctor (OT) · Miller (OT) | Daniels (S/LB)* · McNeil-Warren (S)* · Coleman (RB)* · Halton (DT)* · Taaffe (S)* |
* Provisional grade. Real NFL performance could not be verified.
Best returns: The Rams, Cowboys, Browns and Ravens have the strongest early hauls. Their players have paired real playing time with production well beyond draft-day expectations. The Rams and Cowboys both have a rookie linebacker tied for first in the ESPN rookie rankings.
Disappointments: The Seahawks, Broncos and Steelers have the weakest returns, for different reasons. Seattle’s problem is injury and ineffective play, Denver’s is thin receiving production, and Pittsburgh’s is a quarterback who simply hasn’t played.
Dented but intact: The Titans, Raiders, Saints and Commanders still hold highly regarded prospects, but injuries or uneven play have lowered their grades from draft day.
Trends worth noting:
Provisional grades: Anthony Hill Jr., Kendal Daniels, Emmanuel McNeil-Warren, Jonah Coleman, Gracen Halton and Michael Taaffe could not be independently verified. Treat their grades as placeholders, not definitive midseason judgments.